Lemon Fairy Tail Fanfiction: What are some interesting plot ideas? (2025)

Perhaps a fanfiction where a demon has a unique power that is needed by the Fairy Tail guild. The demon is initially reluctant but then realizes the importance of helping. They could form friendships within the guild and have adventures together, like going on a quest to retrieve a magical artifact.

One idea could be a story where Juvia and Gray get trapped in a magical realm together. In this realm, their powers are altered in strange ways, and they have to rely on each other more than ever. They start to discover new aspects of their relationship as they face various challenges.

One idea could be a new character arriving at Fairy Hills and having to adapt to the unique living situation. They could face challenges like getting along with the different personalities of the Fairy Tail mages living there.

Perhaps a plot where a powerful villain threatens both the Naruto and Fairy Tail universes. The characters then combine their skills, like Naruto's ninjutsu and Fairy Tail's magic. In the harem part, it could be that the main character, say a new character created for this fanfiction, has to navigate the different personalities and affections of characters from both series while they all work towards saving their worlds.

Perhaps in the fanfiction, there is a traveling burger - making wizard who comes to the Fairy Tail guild. This wizard has the ability to infuse emotions into burgers. So, a happy burger might make the eater feel extremely joyful, while a sad burger could bring out melancholy. The Fairy Tail members are intrigued by this concept and start to explore how these emotion - filled burgers could be used in their daily lives and in battles.

One idea could be a character from Fairy Tail having to box against a powerful magical opponent where their regular magic is restricted, so they rely solely on boxing skills. For example, Natsu could be in a situation where his fire magic doesn't work, and he has to use his brute strength and newly learned boxing moves to win the fight.

One idea could be a marriage between Natsu and Lucy. They could have a big, magical wedding in Magnolia where all their guild mates are involved. Maybe they face some kind of pre - wedding chaos like an enemy trying to disrupt the preparations but they overcome it together.

Well, a plot could revolve around a robot that has the ability to copy magic. It joins Fairy Tail to learn more about different types of magic, but some of the guild members are suspicious of it. As it tries to prove itself, it gets involved in a big conflict against an enemy who wants to use its magic - copying ability for evil. Also, there could be a story where a Fairy Tail mage creates a robotic sidekick. They go on adventures together, and the robot has unique abilities that complement the mage's magic, like being able to analyze an opponent's weaknesses quickly.

Another plot could be Aries traveling back in time. She could end up in a time when the Fairy Tail guild was first founded and interact with the founders. This would give her a chance to see how the guild has evolved and also allow her to contribute to the early days of the guild in some unexpected ways, like using her knowledge of future events to prevent a disaster that could have ended the guild before it really began.

Maybe there could be a big competition at the highschool, like a magical sports event. Different characters from Fairy Tail would form teams and compete, with rivalries and friendships being tested. For example, Natsu's team against Gray's team, and there could be some comical moments as well as intense battles.